1940-1949
1942 |
|||
 Rogers Hornsby 1935 Diamond Stars |
|||
1944 |
|||
 Kenesaw Mountain Landis 1960 Fleer |
|||
1945 |
|||
 Roger Bresnahan 1909 T206 |
 Roger Bresnahan 1909 T206 |
 Roger Bresnahan 1911 T3 |
 Dan Brouthers 1887 Old Judge Cigarettes |
 Dan Brouthers 1888 Old Judge & Gypsy Queen Cigarettes |
 Fred Clarke 1909 T206 |
 Fred Clarke 1909 T206 |
 Fred Clarke 1909 T206 |
 Fred Clarke 1911 Mecca |
 Fred Clarke 1911 T205 |
 Fred Clarke 1911 T3 |
 Jimmy Collins 1909 T206 |
 Ed Delahanty 1887 Old Judge Cigarettes |
 Hugh Duffy 1906 Fan Craze |
 Hugh Duffy 1909 T206 |
 Hugh Duffy 1911 T205 |
 Hughie Jennings 1909 T206 |
 Hughie Jennings 1909 T206 |
 Hughie Jennings 1909 T206 |
 Hughie Jennings 1913 National Game |
 Hughie Jennings 1915 Sporting News |
 Hughie Jennings 1916 Tango Eggs |
 King Kelly 1887 Allen & Ginter Cigarettes |
 Jim O'Rourke 1887 Old Judge Cigarettes |
 Wilbert Robinson 1923 W515 |  Wilbert Robinson 1927 York Caramel |
||
1946 |
|||
 Jesse Burkett 1909 Ramly |
 Frank Chance 1909 T206 |
 Frank Chance 1909 T206 |
 Frank Chance 1909 T206 |
 Frank Chance 1911 T3 |
 Jack Chesbro 1904 Fan Craze |
 Jack Chesbro 1909 T206 |
 Johnny Evers 1909 T206 |
 Johnny Evers 1909 T206 |
 Johnny Evers 1909 T206 |
 Johnny Evers 1913 National Game |
 Clark Griffith 1909 T206 |
 Clark Griffith 1909 T206 |
 Clark Griffith 1911 T3 |
 Tommy McCarthy 1887 Old Judge Cigarettes |
 Joe McGinnity 1906 Fan Craze |
 Joe McGinnity 1909 T206 |
 Eddie Plank 1904 Fan Craze |
 Eddie Plank 1909 American Caramel |
 Eddie Plank 1910 Standard Caramel |
 Joe Tinker 1909 T206 |
 Joe Tinker 1909 T206 |
 Joe Tinker 1909 T206 |
 Joe Tinker 1909 T206 |
 Joe Tinker 1911 T205 |
 Joe Tinker 1911 T3 |
 Rube Waddell 1909 T206 |
 Rube Waddell 1909 T206 |
 Ed Walsh 1909 T206 |
 Ed Walsh 1913 National Game |
||
1947 |
|||
 Mickey Cochrane 1933 Goudey |
 Mickey Cochrane 1936 Diamond Stars |
 Frankie Frisch 1934 Goudey |
 Lefty Grove 1934 Goudey PSA 7 |
 Lefty Grove 1934 Goudey PSA 6 |
 Carl Hubbell 1935 Diamond Stars |
 Carl Hubbell 1939 Play Ball |
|
1948 |
|||
 Herb Pennock 1929 Kashin |
 Herb Pennock 1933 |
 Pie Traynor 1926 Spalding Champions |
 Pie Traynor 1935 Diamond Stars |
1949 |
|||
 Mordecai Brown 1906 Fan Craze |
 Mordecai Brown 1909 T206 |
 Mordecai Brown 1909 T206 |
 Mordecai Brown 1909 T206 |
 Mordecai Brown 1911 Sporting Life |
 Mordecai Brown 1911 T3 |
 Charley Gehringer 1933 Goudey |
 Charley Gehringer 1934 Goudey |
 Kid Nichols 1895 Mayo's Cut Plug |
 Kid Nichols 1906 Fan Craze |
||
| 1936-1939 | 1940-1949 | 1950-1959 | 1960-1969 |
| 1970-1979 | 1980-1989 | 1990-1999 | 2000-present |